This is Veronica, the author of our first entry on chapter 2. This is what she said about the picture:
"My older sister and I appear in the picture. I am the one with pink
sunglasses (the one on the right). We are not twins, but are very close
in age. She is about a year and 7 months older than I. Growing up, people would always ask us if we were twins…I guess mother was to blame for always dressing us alike."
Of course, now Veronica is a grown-up college student, and I think you'll enjoy her reflections on chapter 2. And just so you know...she turned this in FOUR days before it was due! Wow! It's only being posted now simply because I was too busy to get it posted -- my bad!
Veronica wrote:
One of the ideas that Elkind mentioned in chapter two that caught my attention is that adults and society in general, help mold children; we shape their lives day by day. This idea caught my attention because it portrays children as easily shapeable, powerless individuals giving us adults the power to affect their future in whichever way we basically want. It says that we are superior to them and they are inferior to us. Knowing that we have all this power over them should encourage us to raise happy productive citizens, but the reality is that we are not. With all the pressures to grow up quickly that we assign them, we are raising unhappy individuals that, as mentioned in the previous chapter, are thinking about suicides, drugs, drinking, etc. as a way to retaliate or cope with their everyday stressors. I don’t think that we are doing them any good by setting such high expectations and pressures to grow up quickly.
I agree with his idea that adults always expect children to adjust to their schedules. We as adults can get caught up into our daily routines, and because of our stress, forget that they too have their own things going on. Children encounter new situations everyday that cause stress in their lives, and we simply put them off because our stressors seem more important to us than theirs. I had never before thought of it this way, but it makes perfect sense now. We as adults are egocentric and just think about getting our needs met, and we simply expect them to contribute to our needs rather than us contributing to theirs. The hurried children of today are our future. How can we expect them to be less of what we are now if that is all they see from us today?
Another point that Elkind made was that parents start their children early in sports to help them become more successful later in life, and to carry on “their parents’ frustrated competitiveness in the workplace” (Page 29). I’m not too sure I agree with the idea of making your child join a sport at such an early age. If it is not inside the child to be an active sports-person, then it won’t make much of a difference at what age their parents enroll them in sports. I feel this way because a child like myself, who does not like being active or in sports, will not necessarily benefit from being enrolled in sports at any particular age. It must be very frustrating not to be heard if you are a child who is in a sport simply because your parents want you to be there. I agree with Elkind that placing your children in sports will help them acquire important social skills by meeting new children and interacting with them; they will learn to cooperate and to be competitive. But I don’t see how that would motivate them into liking the sport if it really is not their thing. This reminds me of how my older sister always wanted me to follow within her footsteps and join every single sport that she did. I felt very pressured to do so not only by her but also by my parents who wanted me to join. I did end up going to practice for a couple of those sports, but I always ended up withdrawing when I was there and quitting because it simply was not my thing. Being pressured to be there created insecurities in me rather than fostering my “self-esteem and feelings of competence” (Page 31). I wanted to be the simple, passive child that I was, not the active, outgoing, and sporty child that my sister has always been. I was fortunate enough that my parents were never too pushy and never really forced me to stay, but I can sympathize with the children that perhaps are not as fortunate as I am and are pressured to join a sport. I am not saying that joining a sport at an early age is a bad thing, not at all. On the contrary, if your child seems to really enjoy it by all means support them. Parents should stop buying into the pressures of society. They should realize that the one size fits all model is not always applicable when dealing with children.They all have their own unique personalities that should be taken into consideration when making important decisions that will inevitably impact their lives.
I really liked the idea of organizing play groups as an alternative for parents so that their kids can be safe ,use their imaginations, and have a great time as they play. Kids have a huge imagination and just about any simple prop will do to get them started. This can be very engaging and fun not only for them but also for adults. I have done this in the past with my seven-year-old brother, and it is so much fun! I truly believe that giving him the opportunity to create enhances his creativity and also increases his self-esteem. At the end of the day, experiences such as these are priceless because they allow for wonderful bonding opportunities.
I also agree that children today are being pressured to learn to read very quickly. I remember when my little brother was learning to read, and he had to keep up with the pace of the class. Sometimes he seemed very frustrated. I honestly felt bad for him. There is also pressure to learn to write, to learn to do math quickly, etc. My little brother is currently in first grade and he is already learning to multiply! I see him stressed out many times. I remember I had to learn to multiply around fourth grade. I find it too overwhelming for kids now-a-days. No wonder they sometimes wake up not wanting to go to school.
Veronica, your post was so insightful, and I truly enjoyed reading it. The part of chapter 2 about adults not recognizing stress in children being as important as their own really stood out to me too. I have noticed this in many adults, that they are egocentric and the things they have going on are much more important than their children. It is so very sad to me to see children being pushed aside simply because a parent is thinking that what they are feeling or doing is more important. I agree that children have stressors in their own lives that are just as valid, if not moreso, than adults. For example, some parents may put the responsibility of watching younger sibblings and cleaning the house on the elder children, because they want to go out with their friends. I find this completely selfish, the children may also want to go out with their own friends, may have important homework assignments and do not need the stress of being the "parent" for their younger sibblings.
ReplyDeleteAs I was growing up, the oldest child of 4, I was expected to do these things. I was expected to clean the house, have dinner fixed, make sure my sibblings had done their homework and get everyone ready for bed. I cannot blame my mom, being a single mom, for what had to be done, however I do feel that I lost a lot of my childhood. I always had to be responsible and in charge.
When I am a parent I am going to remember the feelings I had, of just wanting to be a kid that did homework after school. I am going to remember that although kids stress may not seem important, to them it truly is, so they need to be validated.
This topic of stress is an interesting one to me.
ReplyDeleteAs a parent, I've observed levels of stress in children (my own son and others' children) that is profound. While we (adults) might believe children couldn't possibly have the level or kinds of stress that we have (whatever our reason for thinking so), it is important to realize that their stress is just as potent to them as ours is to us. Further, children are inexperienced in coping with stress, leading them to behave in all sorts of ways (both desirable and not). Ultimately, it's up to us as parents (and societal leaders) to show our children the ropes; to guide them towards ways to manage their stressors and/or eliminate them. Not doing so (or adding to the burden) is a huge let down for them. Likewise, when we offer nothing but admonishment for those negative stress-inspired behaviors, a mixture of depression, alienation, and poor coping skills seems unavoidable.
However, guiding another takes time and requires a slow pace. It requires being present and at peace. It means that there must be a balance between doing and not doing -- something that is a bit counter-culture. Can we do it? Can we step out of the tornado and guide our children? If this blog is any indication, I think the answer is yes.
Aglaed Garcia
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Veronica, adults are pushing children too much and children are becoming very stressed. Children have the pressure to grow up quickly and their level of stress keeps getting higher. For instance, some children go to school with a high level of stress because of issues at home. As a result, they do poorly academically because they are too stress to concentrate in school. At this point they are not only facing problems at home, but in school as well. Their level of stress gets higher until they have multiple stressors they have to cope with.
I fully agree with Elkind and Veronica that parents in today’s society put tremendous unwanted stress on their children in order to see that they will succeed. Especially when it comes to sports. In today’s society, many children are living out their parents’ hopes and dreams, not because the child wants to do it, but because the parents want to build character and self esteem! Yeah, right! Elkind is absolutely right when he says that it does build self esteem, however, it harbors and restricts the good kind sometimes. This is because far more excellent players are played far more than so-so players. Many American parents place their children on competitive team sports only to see if they could be the next prodigies.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Erica as well on the fact that children these days are being over scheduled and booked in order for them to look like a well-rounded student. Going from school, to karate, to soccer, to home, to bed, eat and repeating the following day is exhausting and tiresome. I cannot even hold down a full class load and a part time job without complaining. How do theses little kids do it?
Hi Veronica! Great post! Although I am definitely reminded of ways in which my parents 'hurried' my own childhood, I have found MANY more clear-cut examples of this type of parenting in my aunt’s family. This is also why I loved quite a few things that you discussed. I truly enjoyed reading about your thoughts on parental egocentrism, scheduling stressors, and organizing playgroups. My aunt and uncle are definitely a part of the group of parents who schedule their children's lives extremely full. One example that I remembered immediately while reading this chapter was something my aunt told my mom a few weeks ago. My aunt was complaining to my mom because one of her son's friends had come over. When my mom asked why he was over, my aunt replied that he needed a friend to come over.
ReplyDeleteAnyways, when my mom asked why he needed a friend to come over, my aunt replied, "Well if he didn't have a friend over, he would drive us crazy!"
Now when my mom told me this, I immediately thought, ‘No! He did not need a friend to come over- he's 15! He is definitely able to entertain himself!’ And then I thought, ‘wow! My aunt and uncle definitely have a unique view of parenting- is it all about them?’ My cousin has a younger sister to play with, countless games and books, and he is also involved in MANY activities and sports! After reading Elkind, I now realize how egocentric my aunt and uncle are. I really think that the ideas Elkind presents can definitely help them, as well as every parent!
After being exposed to the idea that stressors on parents effect how they are parents, I hope that I will not parent out of such selfish and insensitive ways. Although many parents have good intentions about scheduling their children in activities (which it sounds like your parents really did, Veronica), I am definitely more aware of the ways in which the intentions of parents drive them to do destructive things to their children and the ways in which they spend their free time.
I am also unsure about the idea of making a child join a sport at an early age. I sometimes wonder when I see children playing sports, if they are playing for themselves or for their parents. I was like you as a child and was passive and not competitive at all, so sports were not really my thing either. I do realize that just because sports were not my thing as a child that it could be for other children. I have seen sports be a positive thing for children. For some it helps give them confidence, raises their self-esteem, and they make new friends. On the other hand, I have seen parents at children’s games yelling on the sideline and I am appalled. Things like that make me realize that those children are there for their parents not for themselves. It makes me wonder what they are getting out of it other than embarrassment because their parents make a scene at their games.
ReplyDeleteI also agreed with Elkind that children are being pressured to learn to read quickly. I think that children are being pressured to learn everything quickly. I think it is sad that they are being taught material that they are not ready to comprehend yet. It is crazy to teach a first grader multiplication. If I were growing up today, I don’t know if I could make it through school.
-Melissa Kyhn
I too agree that placing young children in sports is a great way to teach them the fundamental skills of socialization and competitiveness. But I also feel that sometimes parents go overboard with wanting to always win. It seems today that winning means more to the parents than it does to the child. Playing sports at a young age should be fun and enjoyable, not stressful.
ReplyDeleteOne of my oldest friends told me she quit playing basketball at the age of twelve because the game was no longer fun for her. Of course she loved the game, but when it became too much about wins and losses, she couldn't handle the stress. Although her passion for the game still exists, she has since then never played the game again.
Sharon V.